ETERNITY:
A ROMANTIC-COMEDY TO DIE FOR!
By Nico Beland
Movie Review: **** out of 4
A24 AND APPLE ORIGINAL FILMS
Callum Turner, Elizabeth Olsen, and Miles Teller in Eternity
A romance in the afterlife that doesn’t involve the Corpse Bride begins in Eternity, a romantic-comedy from A24 and David Freyne in his directorial debut. I’ll be honest, I almost forgot this was even coming out, I never saw the trailer in theaters or online and the only thing that jogged my memory was a poster and a standee in one of my movie theater lobbies.
But I love many of the people involved in this so, I decided to give it a shot and…I am so glad I did becauseEternity is fantastic. This is a very funny, touching and incredibly clever rom-com that plays around with the classic Love Triangle formula and crafts something truly special out of it.
The film follows Joan (Elizabeth Olsen-Godzilla (2014), Marvel Cinematic Universe, Wind River), a woman who enters the afterlife following her death where souls have only one week to decide where they want to spend their eternity. This leads her to make the impossible decision of choosing between the man she spent her life with, Larry Cutler (Miles Teller-Whiplash, The Divergent Series, Top Gun: Maverick) and her first love, Luke (Callum Turner-Green Room, Fantastic Beasts 2 and 3, The Boys in the Boat) who died young and has waited decades for her arrival.
The film also stars Da’Vine Joy Randolph (Dolemite is My Name, The Lost City, The Holdovers) as Anna, John Early (30 Rock, Search Party, Late Night) as Ryan, and Olga Merediz (Music of the Heart, Shades of Blue, Orange Is the New Black) as Karen.
Overall, Eternity is absolutely delightful and one of the most pleasant surprises I had all year with a film. I came in very cold with the only knowledge I had being the poster and a plot synopsis I read online and was laughing and charmed throughout.
The movie plays like a lot of Love Triangle films with very familiar tropes, but unlike those shmaltzy and formulaic Love Triangle rom-coms cranked out by Hollywood, this one actually has some smart writing and endearing performances to make it work. The fact that it’s a romance movie that takes place in the afterlife where a woman’s soul has to choose between the souls of her two loves for whom she wants to spend her eternity with is an ingenious way to utilize the Love Triangle because it’s between two men from completely different points in her life and the first man even died before she met the second.
Despite there being a fair amount of tension and a rivalry between the two men, neither one of them is painted like the antagonist and just want to live their eternity with the one they love. Both Teller and Turner are very charming and have wonderful chemistry with Olsen as well as each other as the film progresses.
Elizabeth Olsen is great here and gives some of her best acting in a while, I mostly know her for playing Scarlet Witch in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and she played that part well, but this really showcases her skills as an actress. She nails comedic reactions while also commanding scenes when situations involving her dead husbands get out of hand and in the end bringing a lot of heart to the movie whether she’s with Teller, Turner, or both.
The film also has interesting world building with an afterlife that I can best describe as a less quirky version ofBeetlejuice’s afterlife where there are people at the front desk when new arrivals come in and seems almost like some sort of hotel or fancy apartment for souls before they go to their eternity. However, it still very imaginative and visually unique in a lot of areas such as a dark tunnel that shows people’s memories almost like a theme park attraction, the sky literally being like a sheet that goes up and down when changing from night to day is pretty appealing, and there’s a wild chase between Olsen and security guards through her history during the climax.
Eternity is honestly a perfect date movie in the best way; it’s a solid love story with both a heart and a brain that’s elevated by its charming leads and imaginative storytelling and ideas. It’s right up there with Spike Jonze’s Her as one of the best, odd romantic comedies that’s as sweet as it is surreal, definitely worth your time.









