THE SHEEP DETECTIVES:
A TRULY DELIGHTFUL ANIMAL MYSTERY WITH BOLD MORALS!
By Nico Beland
Movie Review: *** ½ out of 4
MGM
Hugh Jackman in The Sheep Detectives
Well, this movie certainly took me by surprise. A flock of talking sheep tries to solve the murder of their shepherd in The Sheep Detectives, the new film from Kyle Balda (The Lorax, Minions 1 and 2, Despicable Me 3), who’s best known for his work with Illumination Entertainment. The film is based on the 2005 novel, Three Bags Full by Leonie Swann, which I’ve never read, and because of that, I’m judging this solely as a movie.
I can’t say I was particularly excited for this movie because the trailers and marketing just made it look like a typical dumb talking animal kids movie like the live-action Scooby-Doo movies or Beverly Hills Chihuahua. Yeah, it didn’t look great, but to my surprise, the film received very positive reviews and word of mouth, so I decided to give it a look and found The Sheep Detectives absolutely charming.
While I can’t say it reaches Paddington-level, this is a really solid and well-crafted family film that doesn’t talk down to its audience and addresses very bold themes, especially for a movie for children. It’s a very sweet, charming movie about talking sheep that’s also a great murder-mystery film at the same time, it’s like Knives Out if Benoit Blanc was a sheep and explored themes of death.
The film follows George Hardy (Hugh Jackman-X-Men franchise, The Prestige, Prisoners), a shepherd who lives in a meadow outside the English village of Denbrook and spends most of his time isolated from society and reading murder mystery stories to his flock of sheep. But when George is suddenly murdered, murder-mystery aficionado and Shetland sheep Lily (voiced by Julia Louis Dreyfus-Seinfeld, Veep, Marvel Cinematic Universe), a Merino sheep who always keeps his memories Mopple (voiced by Chris O’Dowd-Bridesmaids, Thor: The Dark World, Molly’s Game), and loner black winter sheep Sebastian (voiced by Bryan Cranston-Breaking Bad, Argo, Kung Fu Panda 3 and 4) decide to solve the mystery of who murdered their shepherd with the aid of clumsy local policeman, Tim Derry (Nicholas Braun-Sky High, The Perks of Being a Wallflower, Freaks of Nature).
The film also stars Nicholas Galitzine (The Craft: Legacy, Bottoms, Masters of the Universe (2026)) as Elliot Matthews, Molly Gordon (Booksmart, Good Boys, Theater Camp) as George’s daughter Rebecca Hampstead, Hong Chau (The Whale, The Menu, Asteroid City) as Beth Pennock, Emma Thompson (Harry Potter franchise, Love Actually, Saving Mr. Banks) as Lydia Harbottle, Tosin Cole (EastEnders: E20, Doctor Who, Supercell) as Caleb Merrow, Kobna Holdbrook-Smith (Justice League, The Commuter, Mary Poppins Returns) as Reverend Hillcoate, Conleth Hill (Whatever Works, Game of Thrones, Vienna Blood) as Ham Gilyard, and Mandeep Dhillon (Some Girls, After Life, MobLand) as Postwoman Jo; and features the voices of Regina Hall (Scary Movie franchise, Girls Trip, One Battle After Another) as Cloud, Patrick Stewart (Star Trek: The Next Generation, X-Men franchise, Green Room) as Sir Richfield, Bella Ramsey (Game of Thrones, The Last of Us, Chicken Run: Dawn of the Nugget) as Zora, Rhys Darby (Our Flag Means Death, What We Do in the Shadows, Jumanji 2 and 3) as Wool-Eyes, and Brett Goldstein (Ted Lasso, Shrinking, Office Romance) as Reggie and Ronnie.
Overall, The Sheep Detectives is a witty, heartfelt, and solidly crafted mystery that kids and even adults are sure to fall in love with. It isn’t a movie that talks down to kids or is filled with pop-culture references, song and dance numbers, or fart jokes; it’s a family film that treats kids with intelligence and gives them something that’s fun, wholesome, and smart.
I will say it’s not a very deep murder-mystery, and if you’ve ever seen a murder-mystery film before, you can pretty much pick up on the details, and it can come off as somewhat formulaic. But for a movie that’s essentially a kids' first murder-mystery, it’s interesting and compelling enough for them to put the pieces together, and above all, hit them in the feels with some heavy subject matter like understanding death and trying to cope with it.
Despite its laidback and upbeat tone, The Sheep Detectives cranks up the emotion and drama, and even though the film is for kids, they don’t sugarcoat it. The movie tackles death very genuinely between both humans and sheep, with the sheep assuming they become clouds in the sky when they die and realizing that’s not exactly the case.
Even though he’s not in it much, you feel the connection Jackman’s George has with his sheep, which makes his inevitable murder all the more tragic because of these early scenes. He gave all his sheep names, cares for them deeply, and yes, even reads murder-mystery stories to them. In a very short amount of time, there is a bond and an emotional core.
The film even explores themes such as prejudice with a winter sheep that the other sheep don’t take kindly to because it was born in the winter, which is very reminiscent of social dilemmas in human society. It’s a movie that kids will surely sink their teeth into and learn very important life lessons along the way, and in this age where studios will crank out dumbed-down and formulaic family entertainment, it’s nice to see something thought-provoking for kids that isn’t from the hopping lamp animation studio.
Speaking of animation, the animation on the sheep is great and really brings out their personalities via the designs, facial expressions, movements, and voices. There are a bunch of sheep in this film, and I was able to remember which one was which just by their appearance and movements.
The voice acting is also top-notch, Julia Louis-Dreyfus as a murder-mystery enthusiast who’s hellbent on cracking the case of who killed her shepherd, Bryan Cranston as a lone wolf (or…sheep) with a very dry sense of humor and even some heartfelt moments of his own, and Chris O’Dowd who’s quirk is to remember everything I thought was going to get really grating, but it ended up being one of the funniest bits in the film; everyone did great. Even the live-action actors like Hugh Jackman, Nicholas Braun, Molly Gordon, and Emma Thompson bring a lot of heart to the film.
The Sheep Detectives is easily the most delightful surprise I’ve had all year with a film, a movie I initially thought looked incredibly stupid, ended up being one of the most charming films I watched in 2026. It truly is more than just your average talking animal picture, and I’ll gladly say “Less Raja Gosnell crap and more thought-provoking talking animal movies produced by British people”.






